Finding An Acting School
An Interview With Robert Carnegie
By Robert Carnegie & George Williams
Whether it be medicine, law, or bricklaying a first-rate education in the
principles of any given trade is essential. The field of acting is certainly no
exception. But for the young actor, finding a legitimate training ground can be
like looking for a needle in a haystack. While in the area of medicine or law
there are obvious credentials and background necessary to teach these subjects,
when it comes to the teaching of acting, anyone can throw up a sign and go into
business. So what does a young actor do to make sure that his time, money,
energy, and good faith are placed in the right hands?
Research
A good beginning to the solving of this puzzle would be to do some serious
research. There are many books that deal with the beginning actor and how to
approach the business. A very good example of this kind of book is All You Need
To Know About the Movie and TV Business, by Gail Resnik and Scott Trost. Books
like these give suggestions on what might be clues to the better schools for
actors. And there are other types of books, like The Working Actors Guide in Los
Angeles, which lists all acting schools and teachers, and gives thumbnail
sketches of what they offer. A study of these kinds of references will help the
young actor get an overall picture. They are available in bookstores that
specialize in theatrical materials and in some cases in the more general
bookstores as well.
Another kind of research would be a serious study of theatrical history and the
biographies of finer actors. This would serve to acquaint the young aspirant with
ample background about his craft, and prevent him from falling prey to the frauds
of the people who market acting training. For instance, when I was young I read
voraciously about the actors who I admired, and I knew by the age of 15 that I
wanted to begin my training with Stella Adler since she was the teacher of Marlon
Brando. I also knew that Harold Clurman was the founder of the Group Theater, one
of the most acclaimed theaters in American history. So, soon after beginning with
Miss Adler, I enrolled in one of Mr. Clurman's classes. This was all the product
of reading and research.
The Word On the Street
While the above-mentioned research is vital, there is another and perhaps more
essential thing you can do. Talk to other actors. Talk to people in the business:
directors, agents, casting directors, etc. The more you talk to the better. When
certain places start turning up on everyone's list it might mean they're worth
checking out. Some of the larger agencies have what is known as "a short list" of
acting schools. They know first-hand from their own clients what training in town
is producing the working actors.
What's in a Name?
This might be a good time to mention that I worked with Stella Adler personally,
not in a building with her name on it. I would not put too much stock in whose
name is on the building. It certainly appears that over the years, as the giants
of American acting teaching either died or retired, there was no scarcity of
those willing to capture their names and continue to trade on their reputations.
While some of these may be legitimate teachers in their own right, it must be up
to the young actor to ascertain that for himself, before naively signing up for
classes because it has a famous name attached to it. One young actor told me a
story of having interviewed at a school, and was told by the teacher trying to
sign him up, "The name on the building speaks for itself." The name on the
building cannot talk and will never watch you act or explain to you what needs
correction in your work.
Beginning to Look
Once you've gotten to the point of feeling ready to look first-hand at the
schools, it's time to make some calls and set up some appointments. Some classes
permit "auditing." This is sitting in on an actual class in progress. Other
schools permit only an interview, in which the student is told about the school
and is then expected to make a decision on that basis. There can be a lot of
pressure to enroll in both of these situations. Remember it is your career and
life. Wait until you are genuinely enthusiastic before you commit yourself. It
should go without saying that the "audit" is the preferable situation since it
allows you to actually see what you'll be buying. Imagine if cars were sold not
by going to the showroom and seeing them and taking test-drives, but simply by
having a salesman describe all the features to you and then expect a down payment
sight unseen.
What to Look For
An acting class is made up of four elements. Let's look at each in detail.
1)The Technique
There are many approaches, methods, and techniques to the craft of acting.
Stanislavski was the first to attempt to codify what all good actors had in
common and devise a training system for actors out of those commonalities.
Several Moscow Art Theater actors, who remained in America after the theater's
first Broadway engagement in 1913, introduced this technique. They became the
first teachers here of the Stanislavski system. Among the young Americans who
studied with one or more of these teachers were Lee Strasberg, Stella Adler, and
Harold Clurman. This approach to acting had its first real trial and success on
Broadway through the work of the Group Theater (1931-41). Out of the group
theater came all of those recognized in the forties, fifties, and sixties as the
premier teachers of acting in this country, who devised their own approaches to
teaching out of the principles they learned and practiced in the group. These
included Lee Strasberg, Stella Adler, Sanford Meisner, and Robert Lewis. It is
difficult to find a major actor of that period who didn't study with one or more
of these teachers. Brando and Deniro worked with Adler, Pacino and Newman with
Strasberg, Gregory Peck and Robert Duvall with Meisner, Meryll Streep with Bobby
Lewis. The point of this little history lesson: Is the technique that you are
offered in class a proven one with a track record of success?
2)The Teacher
Once you're aware of the technique being offered the next obvious question is,
"Does the teacher know anything about it?" What is the real background of the
teacher with this technique? Did they study personally with experts? If so, for
how long? Does the teacher have a track record of success? Can they produce a
list of names of real working actors who were in their classes for a significant
amount of time? And, there is an old cliche, "those who can't act, teach." It
contains a certain truth, but about poor teachers not good ones. Lee Strasberg
directed Pulitzer Prize winning successes on Broadway, and in his later years
acted to great effect and acclaim. Stella Adler was one of the top actresses on
Broadway. Sanford Meisner acted successfully on Broadway and in films until a
throat operation limited him to just teaching. Robert Lewis also acted on
Broadway, and directed successfully for years. These were not teachers "who
can't." They worked in and around the theater for years, and their teaching came
out of first-hand knowledge of working in the profession. It is a sad truth that
those professing to teach acting today have rarely, if ever, had a real acting
job. They have not been paid to act either on stage, in film, or television,
except perhaps in very minor ways. Their interest in teaching has sprung out of
their failure in the profession. Would you really want to learn your craft from
someone with no first-hand experience or success in the field in which you hope
to work?
3)The Students
This is a vital element in every class. Acting is a group endeavor. It is
something always done with others, working as a team. It is common knowledge in
sports that if you play with others who are better than you, there is a tendency
to improve, for you are challenged and have good role models before you. You will
find in your search for classes that good people have a sixth sense, and they
know where to go. They can be recognized because they work hard, have a
professional discipline, always come to class prepared, and are seriously in the
profession (they have agents and work). They are well groomed and their demeanor
tells you they're serious. You can't make good progress if you are in a group
which doesn't take their work seriously. So you will want to study and examine
the student body and determine if these are real professional people or flaky
dilettantes.
4)The Program
What is offered in terms of some progressive situation, which constantly
challenges the actor and forces them to grow? Does the class remain at the level
of simple exercises, or does it progress to scenes and plays? Does it offer
contact with leading actors who come in and do seminars, as well as agents and
directors who might come in and offer advice, or is it just limited to the one
teacher? Are you given the opportunity to try out what you're learning in front
of audiences, or do you just remain in the protective hothouse arena of the
classroom? These and other like considerations should be looked at.
5)Time To Begin
You've found a class. The teacher has a real background and a record of success.
The technique is a proven one. The students you'll work with are serious and
talented. The program offers progressive and continuous growth. But you must do
your part now. The old axiom, "you get out of something what you put into it," is
no more truer than in the student actor situation. You must give your
professional best to the situation. Devote all your time and energies to the
learning process. Rehearse diligently and always come fully prepared for class.
Take notes. Read every theatrical book you can get your hands on. Study every
piece of good acting you can find, on-stage and in the old classic films. Study
all art, for all is relevant to you as an actor. Give it your absolute all and
pay the price for success, and who knows--we may be watching you someday soon.
--Robert Carnegie is the founding director of Playhouse West School & Repertory
Theater in Los Angeles. He has appeared in and/or directed over 100 plays in New
York and Los Angeles, and starred in both film and television.